Tuesday, 11 April 2023

Global bucks the trend in Scotland

Four years after rolling out UK-wide breakfast shows on Capital and Heart, Global has announced the two brands will not only reintroduce their own breakfast shows in Scotland but get a fresh daytime lineup broadcasting live from the company's state-of-the-art Glasgow broadcast centre.

It means Heart and Capital listeners will hear Scottish presenters seven days a week - on Heart weekdays 6:30am-7pm and weekends 12pm-4pm and on Capital weekdays 6am-7pm and weekends 9am-12pm.

Lobbying for deregulation was never about a blanket desire to do the bare minimum which, actually, groups have always exceeded.

For example, regional FM licences don't have to provide any programming from within the approved areas if the brand they carry is also available on national DAB - yet Global's regionals still do, despite not being bound by the same requirements as local licences.

Furthermore, Capital Cymru has some Welsh language requirements but is pretty much a standalone station with mostly local programming, despite only needing a three-hour weekday show of its own.

Deregulation was about the market being free to decide - and it has.

At a time when competitors have, or are at least thinking about, reducing the amount of programming from Scotland - and political tensions over the border increase somewhat - embracing this USP seems a good move for Global.

Musk vs the BBC and “government-funded media”

Twitter has slapped a "government-funded media" label on the @BBC account prompting the corporation to contact the platform asking for the issue to be resolved as soon as possible.

In response, Elon Musk explained:

We are aiming for maximum transparency and accuracy. Linking to ownership and source of funds probably makes sense. I do think media organizations should be self-aware and not falsely claim the complete absence of bias.

All organisations have bias, some obviously much more than others. I should note that I follow BBC News on Twitter, because I think it is among the least biased.

Firstly, let's establish the facts:

  • While the level of the licence fee is set by the government, the BBC receives no money from the treasury - except for the more than £90m per annum purely to support the World Service (predominantly serving non-UK audiences).
  • Capita TV Licencing is contracted to administer the licence fee and passes all money to the government before the BBC receives it as a grant.
  • The licence fee makes up around 70% of the BBC's total income with the remainder being from other sources including its commercial subsidiaries (BBC Studios, BBC Global News and BBC Studioworks), grants, royalties and rental income.
  • The Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport may retain a proportion of the licence fee revenue for other purposes as referred to in the BBC Charter and Agreement.
  • While the BBC Chair is a political appointment (which, in my view, should not be the case), they do not exercise editorial control and its journalism is completely independent from government - including that of the World Service.

So is the BBC "government-funded media"? As stated above, the World Service is to an extent (yet the @BBCWorldService account doesn’t have this label) but what about the rest of it?

Licence fee money isn't collected by HMRC but does get passed to the government before landing in the BBC’s bank account.

Ultimately, all government money is that of the British people and British organisations but decisions about where investment goes lie with ministers. However, the licence fee is in a league of its own as it can only benefit the BBC so the government can't just choose to redistribute that revenue. If it doesn't go into the central government fund with general taxation, how is it government funding?

Anyway, that isn’t even the issue here! Musk doesn't care. He knows exactly what he's doing.

We’re discussing a three-word tag on a Twitter account which has literally been put there to be taken out of context. @NPR, the primary Twitter account of the US public radio syndicator, was initially labelled “state-affiliated media” - wrongly implying the government exercises editorial control - before this changed to the same tag @BBC now has following a huge backlash.

Musk talks about “maximum transparency and accuracy” and he is only transparent in so far as everyone can see right through him.

This is purely someone furthering an agenda and seeking to discredit objective media that reports facts they don’t like. It’s not uncommon in today’s world, of course, but a platform with the scale and influence of Twitter (at least currently) trying to cause trouble - much like many of its users have been doing for years - would be detrimental in the fight against misinformation.

Saturday, 11 March 2023

Gary Lineker suspended by the BBC over political tweet

How can anyone argue, with a straight face, that a sports presenter's views on current affairs has affected the journalistic integrity of the BBC in any way? Disappointing that it has caved into pressure from the likes of GB News.

Gary Lineker, a freelancer, is paid as an expert in his (or should I say on the...) field typically presenting one night per week. He is not paid to be political - which is the exact point his critics make, and you could say their logic is an own goal.

Nobody working outside the world of politics is actively paid to be political and nobody working for the BBC in any department other than news is paid to be impartial on social media.

If Gary Lineker had a clause in his contract, where would the BBC draw the line?

Think of all the talented actors and comedians that appear on the BBC - and are a huge part of what makes it such a treasured institution - whose politics are transparent, whether that’s from appearing on a satirical panel show or something they said on Twitter at midnight. Should they all go?

We all fund the BBC and expect its news operation to provide facts and analysis without spin or bias. Does it get that right every time? Of course not - no organisation would - but 99.9% of the time it does. When it comes to impartiality, not knowing the politics of its journalists and the broadcaster not taking sides is all that matters.

Let’s not forget the BBC’s own chairman, Richard Sharp (*a political appointment - and that ought to change), was a Conservative Party donor who failed to disclose facilitating an £800k loan to Boris Johnson just weeks before being recommended for his current role by the then-prime minister.

Long may the BBC continue to inform, educate and entertain - and long may non-news personalities be free to express their personal views off-air without causing a storm in a teacup.

*many BBC journalists are among the world’s best and most trustworthy, and the chairman has no influence on their reporting. With thousands of employees, if there was even the slightest bit of interference from the top, we would know about it. However, it’s really not a good look and most BBC people I know would agree.

Tuesday, 28 February 2023

Radio 1 and Radio 2 will never be the same

In an interview with Metro, Paul O'Grady hit out at the BBC following his departure from Radio 2:

Radio 2 has changed, it’s not what it was. They’re trying to aim for a much younger audience, which doesn’t make sense because you’ve got Radio 1. Radio 2 was always for an older audience.

I've written countless blogs playing devil's advocate with the reasons for repositioning Radio 2 while discussing the BBC's focus on younger audiences which alienates older licence fee payers.

While Paul is right that Radio 2 is looking to attract younger listeners than the average age of its current lot, the whole point is to create more of a stepping stone up for ageing Radio 1 listeners.

Programmers may question some of R2's music choices, of course, but that's not to say overlap is the intention of senior management. It isn't. R2 is supposed to be a station for gen X and older millenials.

The issue is not Radio 2 specifically abandoning those aged 55+ - it's the wider point about what the BBC is offering that demographic given the traditionally older-focused Local BBC Radio has also been heading in the same direction (arguably even younger than Radio 2 at times).

Monday, 20 February 2023

Doing community radio differently

Today, we launched BASINGSTOKE NOW - an all-speech local radio station and digital media platform for the North Hampshire town and its surrounding villages.

The service is carried on the local small-scale DAB+ multiplex and shares local information and interesting people, places, and organisations 24/7 - with no music and no cheesy jocks.

Most radio stations aim to drive listening hours, but we don’t expect our audience to be with us all day long.

BASINGSTOKE NOW is essentially your social media timeline but without any nonsense. It’s fast-paced and content-rich, so even if you tune in for ten minutes each time you’re guaranteed to learn something new about where you live.

The station aims to be helpful and make its listeners' lives a bit easier providing information about ways to get involved in the community, what's happening in and around Basingstoke and celebrating the great work of local businesses.

A core element for the station is enabling local charities, community groups, schools, and other organisations to have a new way to share their news and achievements.

BASINGSTOKE NOW is more than just a radio station too, sharing multi-platform digital content to enhance engagement and all features will be available as podcasts.

For local businesses, the radio station and digital media platform will offer cost-effective content creation, sponsorship, and advertising options.

None of our platforms (radio, website, socials etc) is superior, each being one equal slice of the pie.

In radio, the stations closest to our format are the national LBC News and News Radio UK but unlike these we would describe ourselves as a "rolling billboard" as opposed to rolling news.

Our model of community radio was partly inspired by Keri Jones' Alfred project which, in my view, is the best local station in Britain. It produces a fresh hour-long programme each day as well as broadcasting other speech programmes and timeless content from its podcast archive.

BASINGSTOKE NOW is also supported by old friends at Newsquest via the Basingstoke Gazette who deliver a weekly press review. Over at Petersfield's Shine Radio, we partner with the local newspaper and four local schools.

I've always believed partnerships are the way for newly-established community stations to cut through with limited resources. It allows public service broadcasting to flourish and adds credibility.

Petersfield is a far more traditional market, with an older profile than Basingstoke, but even with a music radio station we view everything as an equal platform. Shine Radio's speech content and programming follows the "on-demand first, linear second" mantra.

I love the way we've always "done" radio but we have to be realistic and adapt to changing consumer habits which is what will keep us relevant. People are less loyal to one station given how much choice exists in media today.

Friday, 17 February 2023

Inside Our Autistic Minds - a new BBC Two series

On Tuesday evening, the nation got to see what was the greatest honour of my life as Episode 1 of Inside Our Autistic Minds aired on BBC Two, in which non-speaking contributor Murray Bruce chose my voice to narrate a short film to share his powerful message with the world.

Like everybody else, it was my first time watching the finished programme. How would I summarise it? Real, heartfelt, emotional, influential.

I’m so proud to have played a part in amplifying the experiences of fellow autistic people navigating a neurotypical world. Our brains may be wired differently but, as well as creating challenges, that is why each of us has so much to give.

If you haven’t yet watched in full, please catch up on BBC iPlayer and Episode 2 will also be worth a watch next Tuesday night at 9 📺

You can also see Murray’s animation which I had the privilege of voicing.

Monday, 13 February 2023

Happy World Radio Day 2023!

Amid constant predictions of its demise, our unstoppable medium has continuously evolved to stay relevant in this rapidly developing multimedia world and still reaches around 90% of the UK population each week as a result.

Radio has always been a huge part of my life, but particularly for the last 11 years. In that time, I've learnt so much and my work is a never-ending learning curve.

Being part of a volunteer-led project has taught me an enormous amount because everyone is giving their own time and it's like a focus group in itself with people from all walks of life.

I dreamed of being a presenter from a very early age, which was my primary involvement for the most part, but being autistic makes it difficult for me to engage with "talking points" that don't really interest me for the sake of being relatable.

However, I love working on station sound - programming, coaching/supporting on-air talent and helping others develop their creative skills - and it allows me to focus entirely on radio itself, which is one of a few of my focused interests.

As the years go by, radio never stays exactly the same... but that's precisely the reason it's here to stay - and it will always be here for you!

A Swift boost for radio

If you were anywhere near a radio this morning, you’ll know it was Taylor Swift’s world and we were all just living in it. The billionaire s...